Telehealth vs. In-Person Therapy: What’s Best for You?

Deciding to seek mental health support is a significant and empowering step, especially during the transformative period of pregnancy and early motherhood. Once you make that choice, another important decision follows: Should you opt for telehealth therapy or in-person sessions? At Mothergood Health, we believe that both options have unique benefits, and understanding these can help you choose the format that best suits your needs and lifestyle.

The Rise of Telehealth: Why It Works for Moms
Telehealth therapy—connecting with a licensed therapist through video or phone—has become increasingly popular, especially for new and expectant moms. It offers unparalleled convenience and can be a game-changer for those balancing the demands of motherhood with the need for self-care. Here’s why telehealth might be a great option for you:

  1. Flexibility and Accessibility

    • Juggling feeding schedules, nap times, and doctor’s appointments can be challenging. Telehealth allows you to attend therapy sessions from the comfort of your home, without the stress of arranging childcare or driving to a clinic.

    • It’s particularly beneficial if you live in a rural area or have limited access to in-person mental health providers.

  2. Comfort and Familiarity

    • Being in your own space can create a sense of safety, making it easier to open up about your feelings. You can curl up on your favorite chair, have a cup of tea nearby, and engage in therapy in a familiar environment.

  3. Continuity of Care

    • If unexpected circumstances arise, like a sick child or severe weather, telehealth makes it possible to continue your care without interruption, which is vital for your ongoing progress.

When In-Person Therapy Might Be Right for You
While telehealth has clear advantages, there are some instances where in-person therapy may be more effective or preferable. Here’s when you might consider an in-person approach:

  1. Desire for Face-to-Face Connection

    • Some mothers feel more comfortable and supported when they can connect with their therapist in person. The nonverbal cues and physical presence of another person can create a deeper sense of connection and trust.

  2. Limited Access to Technology

    • If you don’t have reliable internet access or prefer not to use digital devices for therapy, in-person sessions can ensure you still receive quality care without the stress of managing technology.

  3. Preference for a Dedicated Healing Space

    • Stepping out of your home and into a calming, therapeutic environment can help some mothers fully focus on their well-being. Being in a space specifically designed for healing can provide a sense of purpose and separation from the everyday stresses of home life.

How to Decide What’s Best for You
Here are a few questions to ask yourself as you weigh your options:

  • What is more feasible given your daily responsibilities? If you’re a new mom who rarely gets a moment to herself, telehealth might offer a much-needed lifeline.

  • Do you crave a sense of connection and routine outside of your home? In-person therapy can provide a break from your environment and a chance to focus solely on yourself in a calming, dedicated space.

  • How comfortable are you with technology? If navigating video platforms causes you more stress than relief, in-person sessions may be preferable.

Mothergood Health: Offering Both Options to Fit Your Needs
At Mothergood Health, we know that motherhood doesn’t come with a one-size-fits-all approach, and the same goes for therapy. We offer both telehealth and in-person sessions to accommodate your preferences and lifestyle. Our licensed therapists are experienced in both formats, ensuring you receive the same level of compassionate, evidence-based care.

Combining Both for Greater Flexibility
Many of our clients find value in using a combination of telehealth and in-person sessions. For example, you might start with in-person visits to establish a strong rapport with your therapist and then switch to telehealth as needed for convenience. The goal is to make therapy work for you, not the other way around.

Conclusion
Ultimately, the best choice is the one that feels right for you and your family. Whether you prefer the convenience of telehealth or the comfort of in-person therapy, Mothergood Health is here to support you every step of the way. Remember, prioritizing your mental health is one of the greatest gifts you can give to yourself and your child.

Interested in learning more about our therapy options? Contact us today to discuss which format might work best for you!

Kim McCue, PhD PMH-C

Kim was instrumental in the development, launch, and success of the Alexian Brothers Perinatal Intensive Outpatient Program at St. Alexius Hospital.

She completed the Perinatal Mental Health Certificate Program with Postpartum Support International and regularly provides presentations, trainings and didactics for healthcare providers in the community and throughout the healthcare system.

Kim holds a Master’s Degree from University of Chicago and a PhD from Illinois Tech. She’s the proud mother to two boys.

https://www.mothergoodhealth.com/kmccue
Previous
Previous

Understanding Perinatal Mood and Anxiety Disorders (PMADs)

Next
Next

How to Support a New Mom: A Guide for Partners and Loved Ones